Bringing NY Style Bagels to Tampa!
Quality ingredients, handcrafted techniques, and a whole lotta love produce the best NY style bagels.
About Baygulls Bakery
Our Story
At Baygulls Bakery we believe that everyone deserves a good bagel. Our journey began with a passion for creating authentic New York style bagels and then we realized that there were no good bagels in the Bay. So we said "Hey let's bring an authentic NY style bagel to Tampa!" so we did.
Our Values
We use quality ingredients, organic when possible. Hand crafted techniques and we don't cut corners. A good quality bagel is what we strive for every time!
Our Bagels
A New York–style bagel is defined by its chewy, dense interior and shiny, crisp exterior—a product of tradition, technique, and attitude. Our bagels are always hand rolled, boiled and baked fresh daily. We use five simple ingredients and never use any preservatives, dough improvers or mold inhibitors.
Locally Owned. Built for the Flock.
Built Local. Served Fresh. Loved by the Flock.
Proudly locally owned and operated, Baygulls Bakery is more than just a bagel shop—it’s a part of the Tampa community. We’re here every day, rolling, boiling, and baking with purpose, serving our neighbors, and building something real—one bagel at a time.
